Mass law enforcement misconduct news, Nov. 9-15

Matthew Farwell convicted of killing Sandra Birchmore, Haverhill police face lawsuit for killing man, and more

Share

Here are the media reports of alleged law enforcement misconduct in Massachusetts that I’ve tracked during the last week.

State and local

Matthew Farwell convicted

  • “A federal jury found former Stoughton police detective Matthew Farwell guilty of killing Sandra Birchmore and her unborn child. Jurors deliberated for nearly two full days before convicting him on both counts: killing a witness or victim, and killing a child in utero. … Farwell faces mandatory life in prison without parole. His sentencing is set for Feb. 3.” (WBUR)
  • “State Police Lieutenant John Fanning was a familiar figure during Matthew Farwell’s federal trial, though he never took the witness stand himself. … Fanning was the lead investigator during the initial investigation into Sandra Birchmore’s death, and federal prosecutors in Farwell’s trial repeatedly told the jury that he overlooked or discounted evidence suggesting the young pregnant woman was killed. As a result, the case was deemed a suicide.” (Boston Globe; paywalled)
  • “A medical expert for federal prosecutors in the Sandra Birchmore case urged state law enforcement officials on Wednesday to rethink their approach to death investigations, amid lingering questions over how Massachusetts authorities concluded Birchmore hanged herself. Dr. Bill Smock, an emergency medicine physician who has worked for the medical examiner and law enforcement agencies in Kentucky, called for better training to detect possible strangulation or suffocation in unattended deaths. He further pressed for a specific protocol for approaching suspicious deaths in cases in which the victims were in an intimate relationship with a law enforcement officer. He likened such a new protocol to how special investigations are conducted in police shootings.” (Boston Globe; paywalled)
  • “Djuna Perkins, the incoming Norfolk County district attorney, has stopped short of committing to criminal prosecutions connected to [Sandra] Birchmore’s death, but signaled even before [Matthew] Farwell’s conviction that she wanted to take a closer look. ‘What I’m seriously thinking about is opening a grand jury investigation into the youth explorers program and pursuing any criminal conduct that comes up there,’ she said, referring to the Stoughton Police Academy program where Farwell, an instructor, first met Birchmore, a teenage participant.” (MassLive)
  • “[Former Stoughton Deputy Police Chief Robert] Devine began collecting a public retirement allowance of $56,544 a year, or $4,712 a month, a benefit he stands to receive for the rest of his life, according to records obtained by The Enterprise. Less than two weeks after his retirement took effect, a Stoughton internal affairs investigation concluded that Devine had an inappropriate relationship with Birchmore and lied to investigators about it. … The scrutiny culminated in December 2025, when the Massachusetts Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission, or POST Commission, revoked Devine’s law enforcement certification after finding he had ‘a pattern of unprofessional police conduct that may escalate’ and ‘repeated sustained internal affairs complaints,’ according to the decision. … Under Massachusetts law, none of that by itself puts his pension at risk.” (Enterprise; paywalled)

Other misconduct allegations

  • “Massachusetts State Police have reached an agreement with Karen Read to pay the Mansfield woman $100,000 to settle her lawsuit with the agency. Read, who was acquitted of murder last year in the death of her Boston police officer boyfriend, filed the lawsuit against the Massachusetts State Police earlier [in 2026], alleging a system-wide failure of law enforcement led to her wrongful prosecution over three years.” (Boston 25 News) 9
  • “The family of a Haverhill man who died while being restrained by police officers in July 2025 sued six of the seven officers involved in his death, accusing them of violations of his civil rights. Francis Gigliotti’s mother, Mary Clohecy, filed the suit in federal court [November 9], bringing claims against [Haverhill police] officers Richard Welch, Lauren Bonnell, Brigitte Hamel, Kristopher Buck, Michael Mills and Kaylee Sarfde.” (MassLive) 11
  • “A man is suing the city, the Northampton Police Department and four officers, alleging that one officer [Jonathan Bartlett] beat him for about two minutes and that police violated his constitutional rights during a 2023 response to a call about an injured man. … Bartlett repeatedly shouted at [John] Woodside to ‘stop resisting’ as he punched him, the complaint alleges. When Officers Kenneth Kirchner, Matthew Perkins and Elijah Pack arrived, they continued to ‘grapple with and physically strike’ Woodside, according to the complaint.” (Daily Hampshire Gazette) 13
  • “[Martín] Gurfinkiel, a legal permanent resident, said he and [Melanie] Tinoco were at a Target store in the Fenway on Oct. 1, fulfilling an order for an Uber Eats delivery. He said she walked into the lobby to grab a carriage, carrying items they planned to buy. Two security workers approached and commanded her to follow them into a back room. … Boston police arrested Tinoco and charged her with shoplifting. When officers released her that night, Gurfinkiel said, four plainclothes [immigration] agents were waiting outside the police station and put her in handcuffs.” (WBUR) 13
With mom in ICE custody, a Massachusetts stepdad steps up
“I don’t know how to be a father,” sighed Martín Gurfinkiel. “It’s all new to me. But that’s part of life.”

Federal

  • “Courthouse arrests across eastern Massachusetts last week have raised questions about whether ICE agents have violated a new state law that prohibits civil immigration arrests in and around courthouses without a judicial warrant or court order. … Six people were detained by ICE at courthouses on Nov. 3 and 4, according to the Massachusetts Trial Court. Five happened Nov. 3, the first day courthouses were covered by the state’s new PROTECT Act.” (MassLive) 13
  • “A Boston federal judge ruled [November 13] the regime can keep hold of data it retrieved from a Framingham immigration lawyer’s phone at Logan Airport [in 2025] for now, but barred it from actually decrypting or looking at any of the information. … [The judge] said that at this point in [Andrew] Lattarulo’s court case, the evidence points to the regime not having any right to any of the information because it seems clear the regime was retaliating against him.” (Universal Hub) 14

Other news

State Senate moves to replace cap on compensation for victims of wrongful incarceration (Republican)

Earlier [in November], the Senate said it will vote on legislation that would increase the cap on payouts for wrongfully convicted people [from $1 million in total] to $115,000 per year of incarceration and $57,500 for people wrongfully placed on parole or probation. To get a payout, one must prove in a civil case that they are innocent by “clear and convincing evidence,” a process the bill does not change. …
[Senator Patricia Jehlen’s] initial bill this session also proposed a policy change to allow people to settle their claim with a special unit of the Attorney General’s Office instead of going to court, which can be a lengthy process. The Senate Ways and Means Committee did not include that provision in the version of the bill that’s moving forward.

Quincy ditched Flock then immediately purchased Stalker Camera software from a different company (Boston Globe; paywalled)

Quincy residents rallied for months against the city’s use of surveillance cameras that read license plates, joining a national push to hit the brakes on the technology from Flock Safety. Finally, in late October, the City Council heard their cries and passed a resolution, 8 to 1, to cut ties with the company.
But just four days later, on Oct. 23, longtime Mayor Thomas Koch announced the city would hire a different vendor, again with no public input or competitive bid process. …
A Globe review of public records, online posts, and OdinEye’s website could identify only one person involved in the company: John Stroud, a police detective in Middletown, Conn.

Group sues state for records about horseshoe crab harvests (MassLive)

A national environmental group is suing the Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries, claiming the agency improperly withheld records showing how horseshoe crabs are harvested, bled and killed in the state.
The Center for Biological Diversity filed the complaint in Suffolk Superior Court on Nov. 10, accusing the state agency of violating Massachusetts’ Public Records Law.

Sutton residents oppose Kraft Group proposal for massive data-center complex (MassLive)

A proposal to build a hyper-scale data center complex in Sutton has drawn the anger and frustration of town residents.
The Unified Global Packaging Group and The Kraft Group are proposing that the campus be built by 67 Unified Parkway, located off Providence and Boston Road. The campus would have up to 10 data center buildings, each of them 250,000 square feet in size.
On [November 10], the Sutton Select Board’s chamber was crowded with people who spoke out against the proposal.

Somerville city council votes to divest from Israel (Cambridge Somerville Independent)

An order for Somerville to keep its money out of companies that “directly, knowingly and consistently” contribute to violations of international law – specifically in Israel and Palestine – was passed 10-1 on [November 12] by the City Council.

“Following the passage of Massachusetts’ new public records ballot question, The Shoestring decided to brainstorm what we hope to obtain from the governor and state Legislature. That is, if lawmakers don’t undermine the will of the voters.” #Massachusetts #mapoli

[image or embed]

— Andrew Quemere (@andrewqmr.bsky.social) November 15, 2026 at 5:31 PM

“Missy Woods is behind bars for tampering with DNA evidence at the Colorado Bureau of Investigation. Now, the American Civil Liberties Union says her misconduct has exposed much deeper problems and is calling for accountability beyond the former analyst.”

[image or embed]

— Andrew Quemere (@andrewqmr.bsky.social) November 15, 2026 at 9:51 PM

Thanks for reading! If you’d like to keep The Mass Dump running, please consider offering your financial support, either by signing up for a paid subscription to this newsletter below, becoming a Patreon supporter, or sending a tip via PayPal or Venmo. Your support pays for this aggregation project and original investigative reporting. A monthly subscription is just $5.

Even if you can’t afford a paid sub, please sign up for a free one to get news about wrongful convictions, police misconduct, public records, and stuff like that—and please share this article on social media.

You can follow me on Bluesky and Mastodon. You can email me at aquemere0@gmail.com.

That’s all for now.

spotted: a black squirrel

[image or embed]

— Andrew Quemere (@andrewqmr.bsky.social) November 9, 2026 at 4:08 PM